Best of 2005... So Far As I think I've mentioned before, every Tuesday, I check out a handful of the week's new releases. Well, I've trimmed them all down to a "Best Of" list that you can digest in just over an hour if you have Rhapsody. It's got great gospel, slinky French pop, a lot of that hip new/old post-punk stuff, some singer-songwriters, and more. But before I reveal the list, here are a few thoughts on 2005's first quarter crop of music:
Biggest Disappointments:This does not qualify as a sophomore slump: In 2003, The Reverend Al Green dropped religious title and pretense, and got back to his roots with the lovely
I Can't Stop, an album that equaled his best years as last generation's top secular soul singer.
Everything's OK - number two out of the box for Al since being un-born again - fell far short of
I Can't Stop's rough-n-ready soul vibe. If these cheesy lyrics and schlocky production quality is all Mr. Green has to offer, he'd better start shilling for Jesus, again.
Seeking Substance: The songs on the latest New Order sound like cast-offs from the already uneven
Brotherhood (1986) release. And they also brought back those trite lyrics from that same time period. "Hold your head up high/No, it's not too late to try." Who the hell wrote your lyrics, Bernard? the Bravery?
Speaking of which, they try to hard... and not hard enough: I'm all for this post-punk revival, but anyone who strives
that hard to sound like Robert Smith shouldn't be writing songs like Matchbox 20. I think the Bravery mark the end of this great Eighties trend - or at least its nadir. Which means they'll probably go platinum.
Absence does NOT make the heart grow fonder: Hey Bright Eyes, I never liked you anyway. But with all this hype surrounding your two latest releases, I thought I'd give them a go-around. To bad they're not available in Rhapsody. Get with the program, Saddle Creek.
Biggest Wins:Keren Ann,
Nolita - It's
Come Away With Me for Nico lovers and hung-over hipsters. This Israeli/Parisian woman shifts back and forth between French and English, holding it all together with her fragile eggshell vocals, woozy, Sunday-morning instrumentation and unvarnished, acoustic production. The title track ends with a three-minute fade-out of breathy white noise stitched together by violins and a solitary horn blowing a sparse, three-note mantra. This album is beautiful.
Mercury Rev,
The Secret Migration - I'm a sucker for a Mercury Rev record in general, but this one is nearly as great as their 1998 magnum opus
Deserter's Songs. I was hard-pressed to choose just one song.
Honorable Mentions:Dave Holland Big Band,
Overtime - Finally, Dave Holland releases this wonderful work commissioned by the Monterey Jazz Festival for performance in 2001 (or was it '02? I can't remember.). Lively and innovative big band jazz that sadly has no place in a rock mix.
Vic Chesnutt,
Ghetto Bells - Too sedate, opaque and sprawling to fit into this mix, but it's the best thing he's done since
The Salesman and Bernadette. Bill Frisell guests.
Morrissey,
Live At Earl's Court - After 1988's
Rank which was... rank, I didn't think decent live Smiths was possible. 17 years later (!!!!!) Morrisey finally delivers the goods with a great rendition of "How Soon Is Now." Still, nostalgia only goes so far, and that wasn't far enough to make this best-of list.
Random Note:Beck, you're really wicked smart and creative and stuff... so why do you have to ALWAYS rely on that same stupid hand-clap percussion as the signifier for your collage/junk pop songs?
And now, here's the list of Q105's top tunes:
(Open this playlist in Rhapsody)
"Old Blind Barnabas" - Blind Boys Of Alabama
"Oh My God" - Kaiser Chiefs
"Autumn Sweater (Kevin Shields Remix)" - Yo La Tengo
"So Here We Are" - Bloc Party
"Across Yer Ocean" - Mercury Rev
"Homme" - Brazilian Girls
"La Salles Des Perdue" - Monade
"Underwater Wave Game" - Pit Er Pat
"Que N'ai Je " - Keren Ann
"Earthquake Weather" - Beck
"The Bucket" - Kings Of Leon
"Spit It Out" - Brendan Benson
"Highway 5" - John Doe
"I Need Your Love In My Life" - Solomon Burke
"Winter in the Hamptons" - Josh Rouse
"The Sporting Life" - The Decemberists
"This Day Should Last Forever" - Ocean Colour Scene
"Fleashine" - Kelly Joe Phelps